Students of the famous Borden case have studied the properties on Third and Fourth Streets with some interest. Third Street, directly behind the Borden House once was the address for Crowe’s barn, an orchard and Dr. Chagnon’s house and offices. Men in Crowe’s yard, as well as a young girl named Lucy Collette, watching out for patients on the day of the murder on the porch of Dr. Chagnon, had to give statements to the police. Today the area is very much changed and Third Street has been cut off to an abrupt end by the large brick Borden Place East building.
There is a particularly fine early example of a Cape style dwelling at the corner of Spring and Third. In 1892, during the Borden investigations, Spring Street stopped at Second Street. Another notable Spring Street dwelling, which according to Rebello’s Lizzie Borden : Past and Present, was moved back one lot from Fourth Street, is the Oliver Gray house. Oliver Gray was the father of Abby Borden, Lizzie’s murdered stepmother. At the time of the murders, Abby’s half-sister Sarah Whitehead, her family, and her stepmother Jane Gray inhabited the house. This house is often referred to as the “house which started all the trouble” as Lizzie’s father, Andrew J. Borden purchased and made over the house to his second wife without informing his daughters. This made for hard feeling in the Borden house, and it is said Lizzie stopped calling her stepmother “Mother” as a result.
The Cook Borden mansion on Fourth Street also has a Lizzie connection. Cook Borden was a prosperous lumber yard owner, and a great-uncle to Lizzie. Today the beautiful mansard-roofed dwelling is a home for single men and contains eight apartments. The current color scheme of the house is particularly noteworthy, and picks out all of the amazing gingerbread and architectural detailing. It is truly a South End Painted Lady. The round circle motifs on the porch are especially unique.
. At the end of Fourth at the north corner of Borden was the one time location of Hiram Harrington’s smithy. Mr. Harrington was not a champion of Lizzie during her ordeal, and did not speak to her father in his later years. Mr. Harrington was married to Andrew Borden’s sister, Lurana. There’s a lot of history in the two-blocks behind the Borden house, and some wonderful Victorian homes.
